Healthy Choice Pet Supply is a locally owned and operated independent pet specialty retailer located in Chili, New York. Our goal was to offer a pleasant shopping experience and to offer healthy nutrition to dogs, cats, and small animals.

We are proud to offer many lines of all-natural, holistic, raw foods and we also carry a full line of pet supplies. All the foods we carry are made in the USA or Canada. We participate in many Frequent Buyer Programs that offer a free bag after 10 or 12 bags are purchased. We also offer a frequent buyer discount plan of a $15 credit for every $500 purchased. Healthy Choice Pet Supply will handle all the information for these programs so all you have to do sit back and enjoy the savings.   


A Word About Healthy Choice Pet Supply

Pet Food Stores

Meet our Pet Family:



What to Expect

A friendly greeting.

We want you to feel at home in our second home so please feel to bring in your pets for a visit. 


Genuine concern.

Every one of us is a pet-owner. We will treat your pet like it was our own. The goal is to make sure you have as much information as possible to make informed choices.  


Flexibility of Choice.

We strive to carry a wide selection of products to meet your healthy pet's needs but if there is something we don't carry as a stock item just let us know and we will bring it in at no additional cost. This now becomes a stock item for you. 

Healthy Choice Pet Supply located in Chili, New York your locally owned Pet Supply Store.